Medical care in Kunduz, Afghanistan: Making it work
Fighting in the city of Kunduz in north-eastern Afghanistan ended on 8 August. During the clashes, Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) transformed its office space into a temporary trauma unit to treat the people wounded. That unit is now closed and on 16 August all patients were transferred to the nearly-finished Kunduz Trauma Centre that MSF had been building since 2018. The local community still requires trauma care. A medic in MSF’s Kunduz team describes their experience during the fighting and the work that is going on today.
It is busy but calm, we’re recruiting new staff, and the final parts of finishing the hospital construction are happening all around us. But first things first – starting with the evening when the fighting erupted in Kunduz city…
That first evening there was continuous bombardment and shooting so we had to rush to the bunker and we stayed there all night, without any sleep. Patients were not able to reach the trauma unit at that stage, on account of the non-stop fighting in the streets.
The following morning, we got news of multiple victims arriving in the unit, but we could not get there because there was fighting in the street between where I was staying and the unit. Our colleagues were asking for our help very urgently because they had a patient who had a gunshot wound in his chest and stomach who needed to go to surgery very soon and they needed assistance for that.
Ärzte ohne Grenzen
Die Kämpfe in der Stadt Kundus im Nordosten Afghanistans endeten am 8. August 2021. Während des Konflikts haben die Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) ihr Büro in ein temporäres Traumazentrum umfunktioniert, um verwundete Menschen zu behandeln. Dieses Zentrum wurde geschlossen und am 16. August wurden die Patienten in das fast fertige Kundus Trauma Zentrum verlegt, das MSF seit 2018 erbaut. Die Menschen vor Ort brauchen weiterhin medizinische Hilfe. Ein Arzt in Team von MSF Kundus, der aus Sicherheitsgründen anonym bleiben möchte, beschreibt seine Erlebnisse während der Kämpfe und wie seine Arbeit aussieht.
A moment came when the guns were quieter and it was possible to move – three of us ran to the other side of the road to the operating theatre. The patient had just lost their pulse, so we started chest compression while the anaesthetist was looking for an airway. I cut two holes in the chest – to make sure blood could drain out and to allow the lungs to expand; meanwhile another colleague was trying to stop the bleeding below the sternum. We could tell pretty quickly that the bullet had probably hit part of the heart, and it rapidly became clear that there was no way that we could save him.
That was the start of our day of hell. And the first moment of our team being completely overwhelmed. There were a lot of other victims who came in and had to go to surgery: a lot of gunshot-wounded coming in; a lot of people injured by bomb blasts; and a lot of people caught in the crossfire.
Abb. 1: In response to the fighting MSF transformed its office space into a 25-bed trauma unit. The team has been providing care to people injured by explosions, bullets, and shrapnel.
It was a very long day. Many of our staff also could not reach the trauma unit. The night-shift staff worked through the day. Some would take naps and sleep while others worked so we could keep staff going from morning and into the night.
At about 6:30am the next morning an ER doctor called me on the radio, saying “I need your help now”. As the fighting had receded a bit at that moment, I ran with the surgeon across the road. When we got into the unit it was crammed.
Four patients urgently needed emergency surgery – at the same time. We started doing life-saving surgery on two patients, and meanwhile we were doing everything possible to keep the other two alive. The two who were waiting survived and we could proceed to operate on them too. In the end one patient died, but three survived, which is still quite impressive – they all had very severe gunshot wounds and bomb blast injuries. While waiting for space to open up in the operating theatre, all the while trying to keep the other two alive in the emergency room, we still needed to assist other patients who had come in and needed care. We tried to assist them in between working on the emergency cases. So this was a heavy day to get through.
An unexpected case
One of our patients was a young boy. He was brought by his father to the ER with a bandage already on his arm. He wasn’t crying and was just very silently looking ahead of him. I was supervising the ER along with the Intensive Care Unit nurse. The boy looked comfortable and very much okay. There was no immediate urgency for me.
Because the fingers sticking out of the bandage looked well circulated and warm, I took my time in demonstrating to the staff how to do a proper investigation of the hand for nerve damage. Strangely enough the boy didn’t seem to feel anything on his whole hand, which suggested all three different nerves were cut.
I continued and was gently unwrapping the bandage off his arm. I remember the moment the bandage opened and you just saw a gaping hole in the forearm of this child. There was more of the hole than tissue remaining! The father told me that a stray bullet had hit him while the kid was playing.
Abb. 2: Operating theatre of the MSF Kunduz Emergency Trauma Unit, MSF surgical teams perform an operation on a patient injured by the fighting in Kunduz.
I remember the faces of the staff. Their expressions just said: well I didn’t expect that! And nor had I. So we packed up the wound again and tried to stabilise the hand as it was as unstable as a hand can be. For some reason the only thing remaining was the artery going all the way to the fingers, but the nerves were all broken.
Medically, we all agreed that amputation was probably the best option. The father didn’t agree with this. He wanted to give it a chance. We did our best to debride [clean] the wound and keep the tissue alive, and attached an external fixator, a metal bracket to hold the bones in place while mending, to try to let it heal for as long as possible. Up until today the boy’s hand is still there. He will never have a good hand again, that’s for sure. But the hand’s still there and that’s already something that we didn’t expect.
The father has been very friendly, but the little boy knows that if a doctor is coming close, that means there is going to be pain. He hasn’t smiled towards any of us, but we can see him smiling at his father.
Calm – but still busy
After the fighting had started to lessen, we began to see more patients coming in. Many of them had already received some sort of emergency treatment. When an injury had happened to them, they had gone to the nearest hospital where they could be taken care of and the medical people there did what they could.
We are seeing an increase of patients being referred to us from provincial hospitals, where patients had multiple surgeries. And they end up in our ER. And quite often we go into surgery and realise that there are not many options for us to take – there is not much more we can do to try to save this person. Still trying though; trying to stabilise; trying to get things in order with some surgery.
Moving to the new hospital
Here in Kunduz the rebuilding of our hospital has been going on for quite a while. The community has been waiting for the hospital to open up. Two weeks ago we transferred the patients from our temporary clinic to the hospital for the first time. This is new. It is a huge step to open the hospital, although it is not completely finished yet.
What we see in terms of patients coming is shifting from the very active gunshot and bomb blast injuries. Now mostly we see complications with the war wounded who need follow-up from previous treatment and now also road traffic accidents, which are increasing sharply as society opens up again. Everyone here drives on their motorcycles without a helmet; when they fall, they suffer head traumas, which is not the best thing for us to treat as we don’t have neurosurgeons, so sometimes there is little we can do.
Making it work
In the Kunduz Trauma Centre, we’re doing our medical work while the construction is still going on. But the speed at which all the construction team and others are fixing things is quite amazing. They have a real approach of solving problems. We saw a stretcher bearer going to get a patient and having problems passing the stretcher over the uneven ground because there’s too much rubble. In no time, there were people putting concrete over the rubble. It’s quite incredible how all the construction team are helping so hard to fix all the problems the medical staff encounter.
We have the same support from the team who are responsible for the hospital compound. One of them is always on a bicycle, cycling from one department to the other, fixing things incredibly rapidly. Same for supply, you just see medical items and supplies suddenly appearing at the front step of the departments and a bit later there’s another doorstep bearing gifts of other packages for us to treat our patients.
You also have the recruitment part – we’re increasing again. We have exams for staff going on; and we’re hoping to start recruiting mental health officers, which is something that we badly need.
And that’s how it feels for the moment – all the teams really helping each other, together, trying to just make it work.
Ärzte ohne Grenzen: „Medical care in Kunduz, Afghanistan: Making it work. Passion Chirurgie. 2021 November; 11(11): Artikel 09_01.
Weitere Artikel zum Thema
BDC-Praxistest: Kreislaufwirtschaft – von Anfang an partnerschaftlich denken und handeln
Die Klimadiskussion beschäftigt, wie alle anderen Sparten der produzierenden Industrie, auch die MedTech-Branche. Neben den großen Bereichen von Energieverbrauch, Emissionen und Nachhaltigkeit geht es dabei natürlich auch um Fragen von Kosten und Produktabsatz. Der Gesundheitssektor produziert ca. 5 % aller Treibhausgas-Emissionen, sodass wirtschaftliche Faktoren durch den politischen Willen in den Hintergrund gedrängt werden.
Chirurgie in der DDR – In der Provinz (Teil 1)
Provinz heißt hier „außerhalb der Universität“, und sie ist lokalisiert auf die „Zone“. Die Motivation, von einer Hochschulklinik in die Provinz zu gehen, dürfte in Ost und West so unterschiedlich nicht gewesen sein: Nicht Oberarzt auf Lebenszeit zu sein, den Sprung in die Selbstständigkeit zu suchen, manchmal auch weggelobt oder abgeschoben zu werden.
28.01.2024 INTERN DGCH
Sehr persönlich nachgefragt bei Karin Pfister
Was ist das Schönste an Ihrem Beruf? Unterschiedlichen Menschen zu begegnen, um ihnen zu helfen. Welche Forschungsrichtung inspiriert Sie? Die Verwendung von Big Data. Welche Publikation der letzten vier Jahre halten Sie für einen Game Changer in Ihrem Fach? ...
Lesen Sie PASSION CHIRURGIE!
Die Monatsausgaben der Mitgliederzeitschrift können Sie als eMagazin online lesen.